Why Are Insurance Costs Rising for California Landlords, and What Can You Do About It? - Article Banner

What’s going on in the California insurance industry that prices are jumping so noticeably? 

Higher premiums, fewer coverage options, stricter underwriting requirements, and concerns about wildfire exposure are creating new challenges for property owners across the state. Although we cannot control the insurance market, we can help owners to take practical steps to manage risk, compare coverage options, and protect investments without sacrificing essential protection.

Understanding what’s driving these increases is the first step toward developing a more sustainable insurance strategy.

Our Summary:

  • Compare insurance quotes before renewal and evaluate coverage, not just price.
  • Review rebuilding limits, deductibles, exclusions, and loss-of-rent protection.
  • Invest in preventive maintenance and document risk-reduction improvements.
  • Explore alternative insurers or the California FAIR Plan when standard coverage is unavailable.
  • Maintain financial reserves for deductibles, repairs, and uninsured losses.

Why Are California Landlord Insurance Costs Increasing?

Several factors are contributing to higher insurance costs for rental property owners.

  1. Wildfire exposure and catastrophic losses are major concerns. California’s wildfire risk has increased pressure on insurers, particularly for properties in areas vulnerable to fire. Even homes that are not near a recent wildfire may face higher premiums as insurers reassess risk across broader regions.
  2. Rising repair and rebuilding costs are another important factor. Construction materials, labor, contractor availability, and permitting expenses can make repairing or replacing a damaged rental property more expensive than in previous years. Insurers account for these potential costs when setting premiums.
  3. Water damage and aging infrastructure also affect pricing. Older plumbing, deteriorating roofs, outdated electrical systems, and failing water heaters can increase the likelihood of costly claims. A single major leak can damage flooring, walls, cabinets, and neighboring units.

Some insurers have reduced their presence in California, restricted new business, or tightened underwriting standards. When fewer traditional insurance options are available, you may find there’s less negotiating power.

Is Your Policy About to Renew?

Avoid automatically renewing your existing policy without reviewing the market. Start early enough to obtain quotes, clarify coverage differences, and resolve underwriting concerns before your renewal date.

  • We recommend working with an independent insurance broker who understands rental property coverage and can compare options from insurers serving California landlords. 
  • Ask whether different deductibles, coverage structures, or risk mitigation measures could reduce your premium.
  • But don’t compare quotes based on price alone. A cheaper policy may have lower coverage limits, significant exclusions, or a deductible that would be difficult to afford after a loss.

Pay particular attention to dwelling coverage, loss-of-rent protection, liability limits, water damage exclusions, and wildfire-related restrictions.

Do You Know Your Coverage Limits and Deductibles? 

Review your dwelling coverage to determine whether it would reasonably cover rebuilding the property at current construction costs. Remember that rebuilding expenses are different from the property’s market value, which includes factors such as land value.

If your premium has increased substantially, ask your agent to explain which coverage components are driving the cost. You may be able to lower premiums by increasing your deductible. However, this shifts more financial responsibility to you when a claim occurs.

Avoid reducing liability coverage or eliminating essential protections simply to achieve short-term savings.

Are You Investing in Preventive Maintenance and Risk Reduction?

Property maintenance can help reduce the likelihood and severity of insurance claims. It may also improve your position when insurers evaluate your property.

Here are some great places to start:

  • Roofing and drainage. Repair damaged roofing, clear gutters, and direct water away from the foundation.
  • Plumbing. Replace deteriorated supply lines, address leaks promptly, and inspect older water heaters.
  • Electrical systems. Correct unsafe wiring and have outdated or damaged components evaluated by qualified electricians.
  • Fire prevention. Maintain defensible space where applicable, remove combustible debris, and address vulnerable exterior features.
  • Security. Maintain functioning locks, exterior lighting, and appropriate safety equipment.

Keep receipts, inspection reports, photographs, and records of completed improvements. Provide relevant documentation to your insurance agent and ask whether specific upgrades qualify for discounts or improve eligibility.

What Are Your Options if Coverage Becomes Difficult to Find?

Some California property owners may struggle to obtain affordable coverage through the traditional insurance market, particularly when a property has substantial wildfire exposure.

  • If several insurers decline coverage, ask an independent broker to investigate additional admitted and eligible non-admitted insurers that may serve your property’s risk category. Non-admitted insurers can provide alternatives, but policy protections, pricing, and financial considerations differ, so review the terms carefully.
  • The California FAIR Plan may be another option when qualifying properties cannot obtain certain basic property insurance through the standard market. However, it is not equivalent to a comprehensive landlord policy and has coverage limitations. Additional coverage may be necessary for liability, loss of rental income, and other exposures.

Review the exact policy terms and consider the financial strength and claims-handling practices of any insurer before purchasing coverage.

Is Your Rental Income Protected?

If a rental becomes uninhabitable during restoration, you may also lose rental income while continuing to pay property taxes, loan payments, utilities, and other expenses.

  1. Ask your agent about loss-of-rents or rental-income coverage, including the circumstances under which benefits apply, applicable limits, waiting periods, and maximum coverage duration.
  2. Review liability protection as well. Landlords may face claims involving injuries, unsafe conditions, or other alleged negligence. Appropriate coverage limits can help protect personal and investment assets against covered claims.
  3. For investors with multiple properties, consider whether an umbrella liability policy or a coordinated insurance program would provide appropriate additional protection.

Remember that insurance generally covers specified losses subject to policy terms. It does not replace the need for emergency reserves, preventive maintenance, or sound property management.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is landlord insurance more expensive in California?

Wildfire exposure, higher rebuilding costs, water damage claims, and changes in insurer participation and underwriting can all contribute to higher premiums.

Can property improvements lower my insurance premium?

Potentially. Some insurers offer discounts or improved eligibility for qualifying upgrades, but benefits vary. Confirm requirements before investing.

Should I increase my deductible to save money?

Only if you can comfortably afford the additional out-of-pocket expense following a claim.

Is the California FAIR Plan enough for a rental property?

Not necessarily. It has limitations and may need to be supplemented with other coverage, including liability and rental-income protection.

We know this is a tough time to be looking for rental property insurance. To better manage the rising insurance costs in our market, please contact us at New Bridge Management. We serve Modesto, Turlock, Merced, Stockton, and the surrounding Stanislaus, Merced, and San Joaquin Counties.